Close

Bad Design vs. Good Design: 5 Examples We can Learn From

Taking a look at examples of dangerous design alongside counter-examples of excellent design isn’t solely enjoyable but in addition attracts vital classes for designers. They spotlight pitfalls for designers to keep away from and allow us to perceive find out how to translate design theories into options that work in the true world. Jared Spool, the American author, researcher and value professional, as soon as stated: “Good design, when it’s accomplished effectively, turns into invisible. It’s solely when it’s accomplished poorly that we discover it.” So, let’s have a look at 5 examples of clearly dangerous designs, shine the sunshine on how good design makes it work, and distil some classes so we can all create nice and invisible experiences for our customers.

1. Info overload

The Bad: Parking Indicators in Los Angeles

Parking indicators in Los Angeles (LA) have been the epitome of data overload for many years. They’ve at all times been notoriously onerous to grasp, as a result of the visitors guidelines are advanced, leading to the necessity to convey a lot of data in a small space.

How complicated are these indicators? Historically, very—have a look at this instance from the 2010s:

Writer/Copyright holder: Jorge Gonzalez. Copyright phrases and licence: CC BY-SA 2.0

As LA parking indicators go, this instance is already a fairly easy one.

Think about you’re a driver alongside this highway on a Tuesday morning at 9 a.m. Are you able to park at this spot? What appears like a easy query takes numerous psychological processing to reply.

As designers, we’re typically confronted with conditions the place now we have to design for lots of data to be displayed in a small house. The parking indicators in LA could be an excessive case, however many occasions designing for cellular apps means going through the identical issues. Is there a method out—for each the parking indicators and designers typically?

The Good: Nikki Sylianteng’s Parking Signal

Designing an indication to show all the knowledge, whereas being straightforward to grasp, appears like an unattainable job. However that’s precisely what Brooklyn designer Nikki Sylianteng did.

Writer/Copyright holder: Nikki Sylianteng. Copyright phrases and licence: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Nikki’s proposed parking signal was finally utilized in LA as a part of a trial run.

A part of why Nikki’s design1 works effectively is that it’s user-centred: Nikki realised drivers merely need to know whether or not they can park at a spot. Sure or no—that’s all drivers wanted, and that’s all of the parking signal reveals.

Her design additionally made use of visuals, somewhat than textual content, to convey data. The result’s extremely intuitive: inexperienced for OK, purple for No Parking. It’s even designed for the color blind, with stripes for No Parking.

Now if you have a look at the signal, you’ll know that on Tuesday at 9 a.m., parking isn’t allowed. The bars present what’s what at a look—easy.

Classes Learnt: Finest Observe

  • Perceive what your customers want, then design primarily based on that. This helps scale back data overload.
  • Have plenty of data to convey to your customers? Attempt utilizing visuals as an alternative of textual content. Learn extra about information visualisation right here.

2. Thriller Meat Navigation

The Bad: LazorOffice.com

Coined in 1998 by Vincent Flanders of Internet Pages That Suck2, the Thriller Meat Navigation (MMN) refers to circumstances the place the vacation spot of a hyperlink isn’t seen till the consumer clicks on it or factors the cursor at it. The time period “thriller meat” was a reference to meat served in American public faculty cafeterias which are so processed that their precise kind is not discernible.

MMN is dangerous as a result of it reduces the discoverability of navigation components. This provides cognitive load to customers, as a result of they now need to guess find out how to navigate or what clicking one thing does.

Whereas most MMN are present in older web sites, they’re surprisingly prevalent in fashionable web sites. Take Lazor Workplace, a design agency that creates pre-fabricated properties, for instance.

Writer/Copyright holder:Lazor Workplace, LLC. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use

LazorOffice.com has a grid of MMN photos on its house web page. As you can see, this tableau offers valuable little indication as to the place to go. As a substitute, 9 photos simply sit, leaving a few of us pondering an enigma somewhat than interacting with a web page.

Under the fold of their house web page, a grid of picture thumbnails lie ready. Are they clickable? Properly, sure—for those who transfer your mouse cursor over a picture, it modifications to a pointer. However what occurs if you click on on a picture?

“Click on to seek out out!” is rarely a very good Person Expertise (UX) resolution. Chances are high, your customers are going to desert their navigation and discover another resolution in a competitor’s website.

The Good: Course Playing cards on Interplay Design Basis’s website

Fortunately, MMN issues are straightforward to resolve. The hot button is to bear in mind that you should clearly label hyperlinks. Merely including “View mission” that seems on mouse hover will enhance the usability of Lazor Workplace’s web page above.

Writer/Copyright holder: Interplay Design Basis ApS. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use

Our course playing cards are as un-mysterious as hyperlinks go.

For the Interplay Design Basis’s course playing cards, we not solely have “View Course” on the backside of every card to point the motion that can occur, however we even have a hover state with the textual content “Go to course”. Many web sites observe an identical conference, and it is best to too, to maximise the usability of your website.

Lesson Learnt: Finest Observe

At all times label your hyperlinks! You wouldn’t wish to eat thriller meat—and equally, your customers wouldn’t wish to click on on thriller hyperlinks.

3. Including Friction to Person Actions

The Bad: iFly50.com

As designers, we must always add friction to consumer actions with excessive warning, except the purpose is to dissuade customers from performing that motion. Generally, nonetheless, we’d even unintentionally add friction to consumer actions (largely because of aesthetic or novelty causes) that lead to detrimental UX.

One instance is iFly50.com, created for the anniversary of the iFly journal by KLM. iFly 50 is a vertical scrolling website showcasing 50 journey locations, and in some locations (such because the one under), a button close to the underside asks customers to click on and maintain for just a few seconds to view extra images.

Writer/Copyright holder: Koninklijke Luchtvaart Maatschappij NV (KLM Royal Dutch Airways). Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use

iFly 50 expects its customers to click on and maintain for just a few seconds each time they need to see extra images.

The act of including just a few seconds of friction to every motion can lead to tremendously poorer UX. Think about if, as an alternative of clicking to load a web page immediately, you’ve now acquired to click on and maintain for 2 seconds for each hyperlink you clicked in your browser. You’ll give up exploring the web altogether after just a few click-and-holds.

Many occasions, we designers are inclined to get carried away with the latest interplay types or actions, however it’s vital that you just at all times train warning when your design may add friction to consumer actions. More often than not, tried and examined conventions (for instance, easy clicks or swipes) work completely.

The Good: Elastic Scrolling on iOS

Curiously, mindfully including friction to consumer actions can lead to nice design. One among Apple’s hottest innovations of their cellular working system, iOS, is the creation of elastic scrolling, the place in sure conditions (equivalent to on the finish of a webpage) scrolling turns into more and more tough.

Writer/Copyright holder: Interplay Design Basis ApS. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use

In iOS’s elastic scrolling, friction is intentionally added in some conditions.

You can see this in motion above, the place elevated friction happens when the consumer scrolls to the top of the webpage. Friction was added to point conditions the place scrolling is not allowed: and the impact is an intuitive expertise.

Lesson learnt: Finest Observe

Keep away from including any type of friction to consumer actions so far as you can—and punctiliously implement it when you don’t have any various.

4. “Intelligent” Design that Ignores Usability

The Bad: Bolden.nl

Generally, intelligent designs can be detrimental to UX. What makes this error extra harmful is that we designers love intelligent designs. They’re tiny graphical wonders that carry a smile to our faces. Sadly, the vast majority of people are not designers. Even sadder, not all intelligent designs are good designs, particularly after they create accessibility, discoverability or usability issues.

Take Dutch strategic design and growth studio Bolden’s website, for instance:

Writer/Copyright holder: Bolden. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use

Are you able to inform what their house web page is attempting to say? No? Properly, that’s since you’ll have to maneuver your mouse to the nook of the web page in order to see the messages correctly.

Writer/Copyright holder: Bolden. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use

Is that this a intelligent design? Sure, positively. However is that this dangerous design? Completely!

It is a nice instance of designing for the designer, somewhat than the consumer: the website severely diminished the legibility of its headlines in its creators’ willpower to ship a novel design. Whoever designed this additionally omitted textual content to inform customers that they’re supposed to maneuver their mouse to the corners, which suggests the invention of the headlines depends on happenstance. Moreover, even when the headline is revealed, the distinction between the textual content and the background is poor as a result of level that you just can nonetheless see overlapping textual content. This all provides as much as create a user-unpleasant website.

The Good: CultivatedWit.com

Cultivated Wit’s website is a superb counter-example of how intelligent design needn’t put a pressure on usability.

Writer/Copyright holder: Cultivated Wit. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use

Cultivated Wit’s homepage shows an illustrated owl.

In Cultivated Wit’s homepage, the illustration of the owl winks when your mouse strikes over it:

Writer/Copyright holder: Cultivated Wit. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use

Shock! The owl winks at you if you level the cursor at it. Observe the smart allocation of whitespace, too.

The important thing distinction right here is that this doesn’t kind an important a part of the website, so it doesn’t diminish the usability even when the consumer doesn’t uncover this intelligent design component.

Moreover, they’ve a transparent downward-pointing arrow to counsel one thing lies under the fold. And if you scroll down, you’ll see this:

Writer/Copyright holder: Cultivated Wit. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use

And web sites can be intelligent with out sacrificing UX.

The copy (which is legible and has good distinction) creates a way of wit—not in contrast to what Bolden was attempting to attain—with out diminishing the UX of the website. The one small downside is the textual content “Be a part of our e-mail membership” ought to be extra seen, however taken as a complete, Cultivated Wit’s website is a superb instance of delivering a intelligent design with out creating poor UX.

Lesson Learnt: Finest Observe

Intelligent designs ought to at all times be made as foolproof as potential, and/or examined on precise customers. Generally, intelligent designs can backfire and harm usability.

5. Superfluous animations

The Bad: PayPal Receipt Idea on Dribbble

Animations are an important component of interplay design, however they need to at all times serve a function. They need to by no means be accomplished for animation’s sake. Sadly, designers are inclined to have a love affair with animations, partly as a result of animations are so enjoyable to create that we’d not know when to cease.

Vladyslav Tyzun’s animation idea for a PayPal e-mail receipt, posted on Dribbble, is an instance of animation accomplished wrongly:

Writer/Copyright holder: Vladyslav Tyzun. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use.

The animation is fairly, however superfluous. In whole, it takes a whopping 3.5 seconds to see the transaction particulars. A easy fade-in of the receipt could be extra elegant, and since it takes up much less time, higher for the consumer as effectively.

This downside turns into harmful when designers seemingly can not get sufficient of animations. As of 2016, Vladyslav’s animation would obtain greater than 500 likes and eight,000 views. This reveals a misguided appreciation that designers have in direction of animation for animation’s sake. Having perception into the designer’s tendency to want swooping epics over extra direct representations and catching your self earlier than you give in to animations will prevent numerous time and stop many complications. Bear in mind, customers come to websites for a function—we need to present them what they’re after in a brief house and time, not detain them in a grand tour of the gallery.

The Good: Stripe Checkout’s Animation

Once we do animation purposefully, nonetheless, the outcomes can be nice. Have a look at Stripe Checkout’s animation when the consumer receives a verification code:

Writer/Copyright holder: Stripe, Inc. Copyright phrases and licence: Truthful Use.

Stripe makes use of animations to make issues appear sooner than they’re: it offers customers with updates (like “Despatched”) regardless that they won’t have acquired the SMS but. This prevents customers from feeling pissed off at having to attend, and offers assurance that an SMS is on its method proper now.

Rachel Nabors, an invited net animations professional on the W3C, suggests 5 rules to remember when designing animations3:

  1. Animate intentionally: assume by every animation earlier than you create it.
  2. It takes greater than 12 rules: Disney’s 12 rules of animation work for movies, however not essentially for web sites and apps.
  3. Helpful and needed, then lovely: aesthetics ought to take the again seat to UX.
  4. Go 4 occasions sooner: good animations are unobtrusive, which suggests they run quick.
  5. Set up a kill swap: for big animations equivalent to parallex results, create an opt-out button.

Lesson Learnt: Finest Observe

At all times make your animation purposeful: an excessive amount of can kill the UX of a product. Magnificence has to drag its weight and be practical.

The Take Away

Isn’t it enjoyable examples of dangerous design? Fortunately, it’s instructional as effectively. Listed here are the important thing classes and greatest practices from the 5 examples of excellent and dangerous designs:

  1. Perceive what your customers want, then ship that data.
  2. In the event you’ve acquired plenty of data to convey, strive utilizing visuals as an alternative of textual content.
  3. At all times label your hyperlinks! Customers don’t like thriller hyperlinks.
  4. Keep away from including any type of friction to consumer actions, except they’re meant to dissuade the motion.
  5. Check your intelligent designs and embrace them cautiously.
  6. Animation is like cursing. In the event you overuse it, it loses all its influence.4

The subsequent time you frown at an occasion of dangerous design, cease to assume: perceive why the design failed, discover examples of designs that did issues proper, and make a psychological be aware of the lesson you’ve learnt. After which share the love: share your lesson with different designers in our discussions discussion board!

web design

Coastal Media Brand is a leading web design agency specializing in Web Design, SEO, branding, social media, PR, bank web design and healthcare websites. Founded on the principles of goal oriented results, Coastal Media Brand has been named #1 Web Design agency in South Carolina, Top 10 SEO firms in the United States and well as numerous other awards for excellence.

Related Posts